United Nations Climate Change Conference: Political Report from the Ground
Posted: December 16, 2009 Filed under: Analysis, Breaking News, Business, Community, Current, Environment, NZPacific, Opinion & Commentary, Politics, South Pacific Region, US & Foreign Affairs | Tags: anticipation, Arts Culture and Entertainment, Ban Ki-Moon, Bestof, bhutan, British Royalty, capital cities, charles chauvel, climate change, copenhagen, denmark, environmental issues, Group of People, horizontal, Human Interest, Opening Ceremony, People, Politics, Prince Charles, prince charles at the climate change conference, Prince of Wales, royalty, scotland, Secretary-General, Sitting, Start, tahiti, topics, Topix, UN secretary general, united nations, united nations climate change summit, Waist Up, waiting 1 Comment[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen&iid=7390057″ src=”d/7/e/f/UN_Climate_Change_fcf5.jpg?adImageId=8342965&imageId=7390057″ width=”500″ height=”319″ /]
COPENHAGEN, DENMARK : Prince Charles, The Prince of Wales (C) seated between UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon (L) and Yvo de Boer Executive Secretary of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change await the start of the opening ceremony of the High Level Segment of The United Nations Climate Change Conference on December 15, 2009 in Copenhagen, Denmark. Politicians and environmentalists are meeting for the United Nations Climate Change Conference 2009 that runs until December 18. Some of the participating nation’s leaders will attend the last days of the summit. (Photo by Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images)
An on-the-ground view from Charles Chauvel, a New Zealand Member of Parliament, who is currently in Copenhagen attending the UN Climate Change Summit. Chauvel, a lawyer of Tahitian and Scottish descent, is the Climate Change Spokesperson for the Labour Opposition. He has given pacificEyeWitness.org permission to publish his post here.
COP15 – What will come of Copenhagen?
By Charles Chauvel in Copenhagen
Day 4 for me today. Yesterday, the developing nations staged a walkout from the negotiations. This was largely to dramatise their concern about the developed world’s unwillingness to taken on meaningful pollution reduction targets. After negotiations were suspended, there was a lot of discussion over what would happen here over the four days of the Conference that remain. To simplify massively, there are four big sticking points in the way of reaching a comprehensive agreement – the targets each country adopts; the level of compensation to be paid to developing countries; the best way to measure and police each nation’s emissions; and how the Copenhagen agreement takes over from the Kyoto Protocol.
Based on what veterans of the process have been saying, the consensus is that there are four alternative scenarios for how the week will end up:
1. A comprehensive agreement with detailed rules. Unfortunately, given the complexity of the issues that remain to be agreed, and the fact that the US is not a party to the Kyoto Protocol, but is the key player in terms of making commitments for its replacement, this seems virtually impossible. The US has only really been engaging since President Obama’s coming into office in January, and although considerable progress has been made, including developing countries voluntarily agreeing to some fairly impressive emissions reduction targets, an enormous amount of detail still has to be resolved.
2. A political framework with minimal detail. This seems to be the best outcome that can be hoped for. Under it, countries will agree to a set of principles and goals that lack final numbers, with those numbers being negotiated in the two years between now and the expiry of the Kyoto Protocol. This is in fact how Kyoto itself came about – in 1995, countries agreed the “Berlin Mandate” which two years later became the detailed set of rules we now know as the Protocol.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=climate+change&iid=7390169″ src=”8/8/1/0/UN_Climate_Change_3525.jpg?adImageId=8344853&imageId=7390169″ width=”500″ height=”404″ /]
Former U.S. Vice President Al Gore listens to speakers at the opening ceremony of the High Level Segment of The United Nations Climate Change Conference.
3. A ‘greenwash’ agreement. Under this scenario, countries paper over their many disagreements but fail to make and real progress, or agree further steps. A high level statement of concern, but no agreed timetable for concrete actions, would be the outcome. In many ways, the worst possible outcome because it would take huge effort to get things back on track.
4. A dramatic failure. Developing nations,especially small island states at risk of devastation from climate change, frustrated at a lack of commitment from wealthy countries, walk out of the negotiations permanently because they won’t agree to a greenwash. Some new framwork would need to be found going forward, potentially via individual UN bodies like the Food and Agriculture Organisation on land use change and forestry, and International Martime Organisation and IATA on bunker fuels.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen&iid=7390059″ src=”5/7/9/0/UN_Climate_Change_f580.jpg?adImageId=8343219&imageId=7390059″ width=”500″ height=”325″ /]
Delegation from Bhutan awaits the start of the opening ceremony of the High Level Segment of The United Nations Climate Change Conference.
The NZ officials from MFAT, MFE and MAF are really well thought of here – as opposed to the political leaders from NZ. The officials are seen as having worked hard for many years on the technical issues at stake, and have a reputation for diligence, honesty and integrity. Thank goodness for them, even if they make our current Government look better than it deserves. It would not surprise me if the officials end up playing an important role in brokering any forward deal. Hopefully there will be one!
Photos: What You Haven’t Seen of Copenhagen’s UN Climate Change; Watch Opening Ceremony
Posted: December 9, 2009 Filed under: Analysis, Breaking News, Business, Community, Current, education, Environment, health, NZPacific, Politics, South Pacific Region, US & Foreign Affairs | Tags: agreement, attending, audience, Bestof, bhutan, capital cities, center, Chairperson, chinese, city, climate change, conference, copenhagen, day, dead, demanding, denmark, environmental damage, environmental issues, full length, government, group, Group of People, horizontal, illuminated, Lars Lokke Rasmussen, Major, natural resources, Opening Ceremony, Organized Group, Parliament Building, Participant, participants, People, picture, playful, Prime Minister, protest, speech, stand, taking, talking, topics, Topix, UN climate change, united nations, Waist Up, world, writing Leave a comment[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7334794″ src=”7/1/4/e/UN_Climate_Change_5792.jpg?adImageId=8124836&imageId=7334794″ width=”500″ height=”359″ /]
[tweetmeme]
COPENHAGEN, DENMARK – DECEMBER 07: A participant stands in front of the UN Climate Wall during the first day of United Nations Climate Change Conference on December 7, 2009 in Copenhagen, Denmark. Politicians and environmentalists meet for the United Nations Climate Change Conference 2009 that runs until December 18. Photos by Miguel Villagran/Getty Images.
To watch Opening Ceremony, click here
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7328765″ src=”6/b/0/f/Copenhagen_Climate_Summit_a2ba.jpg?adImageId=8125078&imageId=7328765″ width=”500″ height=”333″ /]
An illuminated globe with the writing ‘Hopenhagen’ stands in the city center next to the parliament on December 6, 2009 in Copenhagen, Denmark.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7334026″ src=”6/a/5/b/UN_Climate_Change_8f13.jpg?adImageId=8124927&imageId=7334026″ width=”500″ height=”332″ /]
Member of an environmentalist group pretend to be dead during a protest demanding a real climate deal during the first day of United Nations Climate Change Conference at the Belle centre.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333846″ src=”6/c/f/d/UN_Climate_Change_2fe5.jpg?adImageId=8125041&imageId=7333846″ width=”500″ height=”329″ /]
Members of the delegation of Bhutan chat with each other prior to the opening ceremony
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333899″ src=”c/1/7/0/UN_Climate_Change_d61f.jpg?adImageId=8124937&imageId=7333899″ width=”500″ height=”311″ /]
Ritt Bjerregrad, major of Copenhagen, addresses the audience during the opening ceremony.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333896″ src=”1/1/1/5/UN_Climate_Change_f102.jpg?adImageId=8124990&imageId=7333896″ width=”500″ height=”314″ /]
A member of the Chinese delegation takes a picture of himself prior to the opening ceremony.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7334009″ src=”d/2/2/c/UN_Climate_Change_0bd0.jpg?adImageId=8124954&imageId=7334009″ width=”500″ height=”256″ /]
Members of the environmentalist group TckTckTck protest during the first day.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7334012″ src=”e/a/9/5/UN_Climate_Change_9934.jpg?adImageId=8124933&imageId=7334012″ width=”500″ height=”364″ /]
UN Climate Chief Yvo de Boer holds a candle in his hand that he got handed over from the environmentalist group TckTckTck during the first day.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333848″ src=”6/3/0/1/UN_Climate_Change_3f1c.jpg?adImageId=8125014&imageId=7333848″ width=”500″ height=”326″ /]
Participants from all over the world attend the opening ceremony.
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333871″ src=”0/7/c/b/UN_Climate_Change_4ab8.jpg?adImageId=8125012&imageId=7333871″ width=”500″ height=”335″ /]
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333847″ src=”7/5/7/5/UN_Climate_Change_bacb.jpg?adImageId=8125017&imageId=7333847″ width=”500″ height=”346″ /]
(L-R) Lars Lokke Rasmussen , Prime Minister of Denmark, Rajendra Kumar Pachauri, Chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and UN Climate Chief Yvo de Boer attend the opening ceremony
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7334813″ src=”e/7/2/1/UN_Climate_Change_61d3.jpg?adImageId=8125102&imageId=7334813″ width=”500″ height=”306″ /]
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333827″ src=”b/8/7/8/UN_Climate_Change_a0a6.jpg?adImageId=8125067&imageId=7333827″ width=”500″ height=”325″ /]
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7333828″ src=”4/4/4/4/UN_Climate_Change_21fc.jpg?adImageId=8125072&imageId=7333828″ width=”500″ height=”340″ /]
Lars Lokke Rasmussen, Prime Minister of Denmark, drinks water during the opening ceremony
[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen+climate+summit&iid=7334812″ src=”3/0/9/2/UN_Climate_Change_c82f.jpg?adImageId=8125090&imageId=7334812″ width=”500″ height=”333″ /]
(L-R) UN Climate Chief Yvo de Boer, Lars Lokke Rasmussen, Prime Minister of Denmark, and Ritt Bjerregrad, major of Copenhagen, attend the opening ceremony.
UN Climate Change Copenhagen: Cloak & Daggers As US & Japan Reject Kyoto Reference
Posted: December 17, 2009 | Author: PacificEyeWitness.com | Filed under: Analysis, Breaking News, Business, Community, Current, education, Environment, NZPacific, Opinion & Commentary, Politics, South Pacific Region, US & Foreign Affairs | Tags: capital cities, charles chauvel, copenhagen, denmark, environmental issues, former nz prime minister, Headshot, helen clark, horizontal, Human Interest, meeting, nz, parliament, Politics, talking, United Nations Climate Change Conference, Wangari Maathai | Leave a comment[picapp align=”center” wrap=”false” link=”term=copenhagen&iid=7390183″ src=”8/8/7/f/UN_Climate_Change_ec9b.jpg?adImageId=8392010&imageId=7390183″ width=”500″ height=”333″ /]
COPENHAGEN, DENMARK –Nobel Peace Prize Laureate Professor Wangari Maathai speaks to delegates at the UN Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen, Denmark. Politicians and environmentalists are meeting for the United Nations Climate Change Conference 2009 that runs until December 18. Some of the participating nation’s leaders will attend the last days of the summit. (Photo by Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images)
By Charles Chauvel in Copenhagen
Late yesterday, I was having dinner with our former PM, Helen Clark, here as Administrator of the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). The UNDP is taking a close interest in a number of issues, principally the financing of developing economies as they move away from fossil fuels.
It was great to catch up with Helen. Before dinner, I introduced her to Oliver Bruce, a kiwi studying in the US who is here with one of the youth delegations. Oliver and Mahara Inglis, a member of the NZ Youth delegation, posted a great blog last week . After the dinner break yesterday, a new draft treaty text emerged.
Almost as soon as it was released, reservations began to be added by the major players. The US and Japan objected to any legally binding reduction targets for developed countries, and insisted that there be no reference to the Kyoto Protocol. The EU expressed its disappointment at this approach, and said that reductions targets should be legally binding for developed, as well as emerging, countries. China and India objected to the suggestion that all countries, not just developing ones, should have binding reduction targets. Technology transfer, financing the developing world’s transition and the merits of market mechanisms like carbon trading also attracted reservations.
The Conference session was delayed, then suspended, only to resume late in the night with countries starting to express their concerns in detail and start redrafting. The Chair – the Danish Enviroment Minister Connie Hedegaard – resigned her position – as the session was brought to an end for lack of time. Today, countries have been expressing reservations and positions in greater detail as the Danes grappled with demonstrations from NGO representatives and others locked out of the conference venue because of capacity concerns, eventually providing them with a new meeting venue in the central city. Danish PM Rassmussen has taken over chairing the sessions.
Meanwhile, Tim Groser was doing his best to try to make sure that some positive spin from the NZ delegation started Thursday’s NZ news cycle. At a press conference scheduled for 3am Thursday NZ time, he sat at the press table with a slightly bewildered looking Tom Vilsack, the US Agriculture Secretary, to announce the first contributions to National’s “Global Agriculture Fund”. This is designed to get international scientific cooperation going on the reduction of emissions from agriculture (and, everyone suspects – although it’s not often said out loud – build support for excluding food-related production from international agreements altogether). Details are scant, but it looks like a bit of money from the Canadians, NZ$125M from the US, and NZ$45M from NZ.
In other words, about 25% of what the previous Government committed to the Fast Forward Fund – a PPP that would have had funding research into emissions reductions as one of its key roles. National scrapped the Fast Forward Fund. That’s a pity. Not only would it have done a lot more to kick-start emissions reduction in agriculture, New Zealand would have owned all the intellectual property resulting from it. We could have exploited that IP commercially, or given some of it away in aid to food producing developing countries. Now that it will be funded multilaterally, it would be my guess that won’t be possible. In other words, a lousy deal for NZ Inc.
Reports are now coming through that President Obama, on the eve of his departure for Copenhagen, has announced a US commitment to a 17% reduction in emissions by 2020 over 2005 levels. This amounts to a 4% reduction over 1990 levels. It’s not nearly enough. But it’s the first time we’ve heard a commitment from the US to a target. Now things start to get really interesting.
Charles Chauvel, a lawyer of Tahitian and Scottish descent, is a politician in the New Zealand Parliament representing the Labour Party, currently in Opposition. He is attending Copenhagen as the Labour Spokesperson on Climate Change.